| Most Points | Chad LaCross | 51 | vs. Indiana Tech | 2000-2001 |
| Most FGM | Ray Lothery | 21 | vs. Olivet | 1964-1965 |
| Best FG % | Dave Gilbert | 9-9 | vs. Adrian | 12/01/1976 |
| Most FTM | David Anspaugh | 17 | vs. Grace (IN) | 1961-1962 |
| Jeff Hossler | 17 | vs. Spring Arbor | 1975-1976 | |
| Wayne Poole | 17 | vs. Grace (IN) | 12/05/1989 | |
| Chris Singpiel | 17 | vs. Spring Arbor | 1993-1994 | |
| Ian Jackson | 17 | at Olivet | 02/09/2013 | |
| Most FTA | Ian Jackson | 23 | at Olivet | 02/09/2013 |
| Brian White | 20 | vs. Michigan-Dearborn (at Adrian) | 12/07/1991 | |
| Best FT % | Troy Neely | 14-14 | vs. Purdue-Calumet | 1983-1984 |
| Most 3 Pt. FGM | Pete Smith | 11 | vs. Kalamazoo | 01/20/2018 |
| Best 3 Pt. % | Matt Schlegelmilch | 7-7 | vs. Grand Rapids Baptist | 1993-1994 |
| Shaun Hill | 7-7 | vs. Concordia (MI) | 1997-1998 | |
| Most Rebounds | Roy Charleswood | 27 | vs. Findlay | 1970-1971 |