| All-Americans | ||
| Name | Organization | Year |
| Tom Truxton | NAIA | 1989 |
| GCAA All-America Scholar | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Mark Civanich | 2023 | |
| Charlie Eriksen | 2023 | |
| Kyler Rod | 2023 | |
| Mark Civanich | 2022 | |
| Grant Brettnacher | 2019 | |
| Nicholas Knowlton | 2019 | |
| Joseph Lesueur | 2019 | |
| Todd Mieske | 2019 | |
| Connor Dwyer | 2016 | |
| Corey Bremigan | 2016 | |
| Corey Bremigan | 2015 | |
| Matthew Dwyer | 2015 | |
| Brandon Snell | 2015 | |
| Terence Clingman | 2011 | |
| MIAA Conference Medalist | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Mark Civanich | 2022 | |
| Grant Brettnacher | 2019 | |
| Joel Bickel | 2005 | |
| MIAA Sportsmanship Award | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Mitch Lowney | 2022 | |
| Grant Brettnacher | 2019 | |
| Brandon Snell | 2014 | |
| First Team All-MIAA | ||
| Name | Year(s) | |
| Mark Civanich | 2022 | |
| Mark Civanich | 2021 | |
| Mark Civanich | 2020 | |
| Cameron Ruge | 2020 | |
| Grant Brettnacher | 2019 | |
| Carlos Coeto | 2019 | |
| Nick Knowlton | 2019 | |
| Mitch Lowney | 2019 | |
| Connor Dwyer | 2015 | |
| Cody Knapp | 2015 | |
| Cody Knapp | 2014 | |
| Graham Bennett | 2013 | |
| Paul Wolcott | 2012 | |
| Terence Clingaman | 2010 | |
| Andy Wolf | 2009 | |
| Shawn Floyd | 2008 | |
| Joel Bickel | 2006 | |
| Shawn Floyd | 2006 | |
| Joel Bickel | 2005 | |
| Matt Haneline | 2005 | |
| Joel Bickel | 2004 | |
| Justin Howard | 2004 | |
| Second-Team All-MIAA | ||
| Name | Year(s) | |
| Mitch Lowney | 2022 | |
| Kyler Rod | 2022 | |
| Mitch Lowney | 2021 | |
| Jack Brockie | 2020 | |
| Carlos Coeto | 2020 | |
| Mitch Lowney | 2020 | |
| Todd Mieske | 2020 | |
| Cameron Ruge | 2019 | |
| Grant Brettnacher | 2018 | |
| Cameron Ruge | 2018 | |
| Grant McKay | 2017 | |
| Grant Brettnacher | 2016 | |
| Corey Bremigan | 2014 | |
| Connor Dwyer | 2014 | |
| Nolan Eli | 2013 | |
| Graham Bennett | 2012 | |
| Nolan Eli | 2012 | |
| Max Niehans | 2011 | |
| Paul Wolcott | 2011 | |
| Graham Bennett | 2010 | |
| Jason Paff | 2010 | |
| Alex Lorencz | 2009 | |
| Terence Clingaman | 2008 | |
| Andy Wolf | 2008 | |
| Alex Lorencz | 2007 | |
| Clint Miller | 2007 | |
| Clint Miller | 2006 | |
| Jordan Schroeder | 2005 | |
| Matt Haneline | 2004 | |
| Jordan Schroeder | 2004 | |
| Jerid Winkle | 2004 | |
| MIAA Athlete of the Week | ||
| Name | Week | Year |
| Charlie Eriksen | 13 | 2022-23 |
| Mark Civanich | 9 | 2022-23 |
| Mark Civanich | 6 | 2022-23 |
| Mark Civanich | 5 | 2022-23 |
| Mark Civanich | 3 | 2022-23 |
| Mitch Lowney | 1 | 2022-23 |
| Mitch Lowney | 13 | 2021-22 |
| Mark Civanich | 9 | 2021-22 |
| Mitch Lowney | 3 | 2021-22 |
| Cameron Ruge | 5 | 2020-21 |
| Cameron Ruge | 5 | 2019-20 |
| Nick Knowlton | 4 | 2019-20 |
| Cameron Ruge | 12 | 2017-18 |
| Medalists at MIAA Events | ||
| Name | Tournament | Year |
| Mitch Lowney | MIAA AQ Tournament #2 - Hope | 2023 |
| Mark Civanich | MIAA Jamboree #3 - Adrian | 2022 |
| Mark Civanich | MIAA Jamboree #2 - Alma | 2022 |
| Mitch Lowney | MIAA AQ Tournament #3 - Calvin | 2022 |
| Mark Civanich | MIAA Championship | 2021 |
| Nick Knowlton | MIAA Jamboree #1 - Hope | 2019 |
| Nick Knowlton | MIAA Jamboree #2 - Alma | 2019 |
| Cameron Ruge | MIAA Jamboree #3 - Adrian | 2019 |
| Grant Brettnacher | MIAA Championship | 2019 |
| Cameron Ruge | MIAA Jamboree #2 - Alma | 2017 |
| Grant Brettnacher | MIAA Jamboree #4 - Calvin | 2016 |
| Todd Mieske | MIAA Jamboree #2 - Olivet | 2016 |
| Grant Brettnacher | MIAA Jamboree #1 - Trine | 2016 |
| Cody Knapp | MIAA Jamboree #8- Hope | 2015 |
| Connor Dwyer | MIAA Jamboree #5- Trine | 2015 |
| Connor Dwyer | MIAA Jamboree #4- Kalamazoo | 2015 |
| Corey Bremigan | MIAA Jamboree #1- Albion | 2015 |
| Cody Knapp | MIAA Jamboree #7- Hope | 2014 |
| Corey Bremigan | MIAA Jamboree #5- Kalamazoo | 2014 |
| Connor Dwyer | MIAA Jamboree #3- Adrian | 2014 |
| Corey Bremigan | MIAA Jamboree #1- Alma | 2014 |
| Connor Dwyer | MIAA AQ Tournament #1- Calvin | 2014 |
| Nolan Eli | MIAA Jamboree #5- Kalamazoo | 2013 |
| Nolan Eli | MIAA AQ Tournament #2- Calvin | 2013 |
| Nolan Eli | MIAA Jamboree- Trine | 2012 |
| Nick Ihrie | MIAA Jamboree- Adrian | 2012 |
| Paul Wolcott | MIAA Jamboree- Kalamazoo | 2012 |
| Graham Bennett | MIAA AQ Tournament #3- Hope | 2012 |
| Paul Wolcott | MIAA Jamboree- Adrian | 2011 |
| Andy Wolf | MIAA Jamboree- Hope | 2009 |
| Andy Wolf | MIAA Jamboree- Calvin | 2009 |
| Alex Lorencz | MIAA Jamboree- Kalamazoo | 2009 |
| Shawn Floyd | MIAA Jamboree #6- Hope | 2008 |
| Shawn Floyd | MIAA Jamboree #4- Adrian | 2008 |
| Clint Miller | MIAA Jamboree #8- Tri-State (Trine) | 2007 |
| Joel Bickel | MIAA Jamboree #2- Olivet | 2006 |
| Matt Haneline | MIAA Jamboree #5- Tri-State (Trine) | 2005 |
| Joel Bickel | MIAA Jamboree #3- Alma | 2005 |
| Joel Bickel | MIAA Jamboree #1- Albion | 2005 |
| Justin Howard | MIAA Jamboree- Hope | 2004 |
| Joel Bickel | MIAA Jamboree- Alma | 2004 |
| Justin Howard | MIAA Jamboree- Tri-State (Trine) | 2004 |
| Jerid Winkle | MIAA Jamboree- Albion | 2004 |
| NAIA Scholar-Athlete | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Todd Hack | 2004 | |
| Todd Hack | 2003 | |
| Andrew Hovest | 2003 | |
| Andrew Hovest | 2002 | |
| Matt Sale | 1999 | |
| Goetz Schaefer | 1998 | |
| David Austin | 1995 | |
| Bryan Foster | 1995 | |
| Bryan Foster | 1994 | |
| Tom Truxton | 1989 | |
| WHAC All-Conference Team | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Andy Martin | 2001 | |
| John Brolin | 2001 | |
| Andy Oplinger | 2000 | |
| Andy Lindsay | 2000 | |
| Rob Klinefelter | 2000 | |
| Ben Gilpin | 1999 | |
| Gary Geszti | 1999 | |
| Rob Klinefelter | 1999 | |
| Ben Gilpin | 1998 | |
| Gary Getszti | 1998 | |
| Andy Lindsay | 1998 | |
| Mike Kulka | 1997 | |
| Ben Gilpin | 1997 | |
| Goetz Schaefer | 1997 | |
| Brian Coon | 1996 | |
| Mike Kulka | 1995 | |
| Brian Keene | 1995 | |
| Benny Jonsson | 1995 | |
| Bryan Foster | 1994 | |
| Scott Zbonewicz | 1994 | |
| Chris Keil | 1993 | |
| Jeff Jackson | 1993 | |
| Brian Foster | 1993 | |
| WHAC All-Conference Honorable Mention | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Justin Howard | 2001 | |
| Andy Reiss | 2001 | |
| Matt Desper | 2000 | |
| David Hough | 1999 | |
| Johan Brolin | 1998 | |
| Kevin Wischmeyer | 1998 | |
| Andy Oplinger | 1998 | |
| Chuck Pentilla | 1997 | |
| Mike Kulka | 1996 | |
| Goetz Schaefer | 1995 | |
| Chris Kiel | 1994 | |
| Ryan Leitner | 1994 | |
Please note that All-MIAA honors are awarded based off fall seasons and that the MIAA AQ Tournaments occur in the spring. An All-MIAA selection in 2013 that won Medalist honors at an AQ Tournament in 2014 would have done so in the same season.