| NCAA Tournament | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 2021 | Otterbein | L, 5-1 | First Round |
| MIAA Tournament | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 2011 | Hope | L, 2-0 | |
| 2017 | Calvin | L, 5-1 | |
| 2018 | Alma | W, 2-1 | |
| Adrian | L, 1-1 | Lost on penalty kicks, 4-3 | |
| 2020 | Olivet | W, 5-0 | |
| Albion | W, 2-1 (2OT) | ||
| Hope | L, 2-1 (OT) | MIAA Championship | |
| 2021 | Albion | W, 4-0 | |
| Calvin | W, 1-0 (OT) | ||
| Kalamazoo | W, 2-0 | MIAA Championship | |
| 2022 | Olivet | W, 6-1 | |
| Hope | L, 1-0 | ||
| WHAC Tournament | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1994 | Spring Arbor | W, 3-0 | |
| Siena Heights | W, 5-1 | WHAC Championship | |
| 1995 | Aquinas | W, 5-0 | |
| Spring Arbor | W, 7-0 | WHAC Championship | |
| 1996 | Cornerstone | W, 2-0 | |
| Aquinas | L, 2-1 | WHAC Championship | |
| 1997 | Cornerstone | W, 3-2 | |
| Madonna | L, 0-2 | WHAC Championship | |
| 1999 | Cornerstone | W, 6-0 | |
| Aquinas | L, 4-1 | ||
| 2001 | Cornerstone | L, 2-1 | |
| 2002 | Spring Arbor | L, 2-1 (2 OT) | Spring Arbor wins 5-3 on penalty kicks |
| NAIA District 21 Playoffs | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1979 | Goshen | L, 1-0 (OT) | |
| 1987 | Goshen | W, 3-2 | |
| Unknown | L; score unknown | No records of result | |
| 1990 | IUPUI | W, 2-1 | |
| Bethel (Ind.) | L, 5-0 | ||
| 1994 | Taylor | W, 5-0 | Conflicting records of score |
| Unknown | L | No records of result | |
| NAIA Great Lakes Regional | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1995 | Transylvania | W, 4-0 | |
| Illinois-Springfield | L, 2-0 | ||