| All-Great Lakes Region | ||
| Name | Organization | Year |
| Noah Acker | USTFCCCA | 2021 |
| Jack Beakas | USTFCCCA | 2019 |
| Levi Neuzerling | USTFCCCA | 2019 |
| Vilis Vuskalns | USTFCCCA | 2019 |
| Academic All-American | ||
| Name | Organization | Year |
| Jack Beakas | CoSIDA - Third Team | 2020 |
| Academic All-District | ||
| Name | Organization | Year |
| Jack Beakas | CoSIDA | 2020 |
| All-Academic Athletes | ||
| Name | Organization | Year |
| Noah Acker | USTFCCCA | 2022 |
| Zachary Brickler | USTFCCCA | 2022 |
| Noah Acker | USTFCCCA | 2021 |
| Jack Beakas | USTFCCCA | 2019 |
| Levi Neuzerling | USTFCCCA | 2019 |
| Neil O'Brein | USTFCCCA | 2019 |
| Noah Acker | USTFCCCA | 2018 |
| Jack Beakas | USTFCCCA | 2018 |
| Jonathan Phillips | USTFCCCA | 2018 |
| Nicholas Zak | USTFCCCA | 2018 |
| Lewis Duke | USTFCCCA | 2017 |
| Vilis Vuskalns | USTFCCCA | 2017 |
| Nicholas Zak | USTFCCCA | 2017 |
| Adam Schaaf | USTFCCCA | 2016 |
| Adam Schaaf | USTFCCCA | 2014 |
| NAIA Scholar-Athlete | ||
| Name | Organization | Year |
| Jay Deardorff | NAIA | 2002 |