| MIAA Tournament | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 2004 | Olivet | L 3-0 (30-27, 30-20, 34-32) | |
| 2005 | Calvin | L 3-0 (30-25, 30-17, 30-26) | |
| 2006 | Adrian | L 3-0 (30-16, 30-21, 30-24) | |
| 2007 | St. Mary's | L 3-0 (30-19, 30-21, 31-29) | |
| 2008 | Hope | L 3-0 (25-15, 25-17, 25-12) | |
| 2009 | Albion | L 3-0 (25-18, 25-16, 25-18) | |
| 2010 | Alma | L 3-0 (25-20, 25-23, 25-23) | |
| 2011 | Calvin | L 3-0 (25-15, 28-26, 25-14) | |
| 2012 | Calvin | L 3-0 (25-16, 25-17, 27-25) | |
| 2013 | Hope | L 3-0 (25-20, 25-15, 25-18) | |
| 2014 | Calvin | L 3-1 (25-23, 21-25, 22-25, 23-25) | |
| 2015 | Calvin | L 3-0 (25-8, 25-20, 25-7) | |
| 2018 | Albion | L 3-1 (25-11, 25-15, 26-24, 24-26) | |
| 2019 | St. Mary's | W, 3-1 (25-23, 22-25, 25-20, 25-17) | |
| Hope | L, 3-0 (25-18, 25-11, 25-17) | ||
| 2020 | Alma | L 3-2 (17-25, 25-23, 17-25, 25-15, 11-15) | |
| 2021 | Adrian | W, 3-2 (25-22, 19-25, 25-14, 12-25, 15-11) | |
| Hope | L, 3-0 (14-25, 19-25, 16-25) | ||
| 2022 | Adrian | L, 3-1 (17-25, 14-25, 25-18, 22-25) | |
| WHAC Tournament | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1999 | Spring Arbor | W 3-0 (15-11, 15-3, 15-3) | |
| Madonna | W 3-1 (15-1, 15-5, 6-15, 15-5) | ||
| Cornerstone | L 3-0 (15-10, 15-9, 15-11) | ||
| 2000 | Siena Heights | L; score unknown | |
| NAIA District 21 Playoffs | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1978 | Indiana Tech | L 2-0 (15-2, 15-5) | |
| Manchester | L 2-0 (15-9, 15-9) | ||
| 1979 | Manchester | L 2-0 (16-14, 15-6) | |
| St. Francis (Ind.) | L 2-0 (15-5, 15-6) | ||
| Grace | L 2-0 (15-13, 15-13) | ||
| 1980 | Huntington | W 2-0 (16-14, 15-13) | |
| Anderson (Ind.) | L 2-0 (15-10, 15-6) | ||
| Taylor | L 2-0 (15-6, 15-5) | ||
| 1981 | Taylor | L 2-0 (15-8, 16-14) | |
| 1985 | Marion | L 3-0 (15-7, 15-8, 15-11) | |
| 1986 | Oakland City | L; score unknown | |
| 1987 | Manchester | L; score unknown | |
| DePauw | W 2-0 (15-11, 15-4) | ||
| St. Mary's | W 2-1 (15-6, 14-16, 15-11) | ||
| Marian | W 2-1 (15-10, 8-15, 15-2) | ||
| IUPUI | W 2-0 (15-12, 15-13) | ||
| Franklin | L; score unknown | ||
| NAIA Great Lakes Regional | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1999 | Taylor | L 3-0 (15-8, 15-11, 15-7) | |
| NAIA National Tournament | |||
| Year | Opponent | Result | Notes |
| 1989 | Georgetown (Ky.) | W; score unknown | Bi-District |
| Montevallo | L 2-0 (15-7, 15-7) | ||
| Eastern Nazarene | W 2-0 (15-9, 15-10) | ||
| BYU-Hawaii | L 2-0 (15-5, 15-8) | ||
| Rockhurst | L 2-0 (16-14, 15-7) | ||