| All-Americans | ||
| Name | Year | Organization |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2021 | NCAA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2019 | NCAA |
| Great Lakes Regional Athlete of the Year | ||
| Name | Year | Organization |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2019 | USTFCCCA |
| All-Region | ||
| Name | Year | Organization |
| Carol Haldeman | 2022 | USTFCCCA |
| Lydia Randolph | 2022 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Carol Haldeman | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Chloe Brittain | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2019 | USTFCCCA |
| Elizabeth Lohman | 2019 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2018 | USTFCCCA |
| Lacie Piekarski | 2018 | USTFCCCA |
| Kyla Binfet | 2017 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2017 | USTFCCCA |
| National Athlete of the Week | ||
| Name | Date | Organization |
| Evie Bultemeyer | Oct. 4, 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | Oct. 6, 2020 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | Sept. 5, 2019 | USTFCCCA |
| All-Academic Athletes | ||
| Name | Year | Organization |
| Carol Haldeman | 2022 | USTFCCCA |
| Brianna Medcalf | 2022 | USTFCCCA |
| Ana Parker | 2022 | USTFCCCA |
| Lydia Randolph | 2022 | USTFCCCA |
| Chloe Brittain | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Chloe Goodrich | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Carol Haldeman | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Lydia Randolph | 2021 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2019 | USTFCCCA |
| Elizabeth Lohman | 2019 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2018 | USTFCCCA |
| Elizabeth Lohman | 2018 | USTFCCCA |
| Kyla Binfet | 2017 | USTFCCCA |
| Evie Bultemeyer | 2017 | USTFCCCA |
| Kyla Binfet | 2016 | USTFCCCA |
| Kelsey Ortiz | 2016 | USTFCCCA |
| NAIA Scholar-Athlete | ||
| Name | Year | |
| Amanda Portis | 2003 | |
| Amanda Portis | 2002 | |